WASHINGTON -- Legislators who sent a sweeping anti-terrorism bill to
President Bush this week proudly say that the most controversial surveillance
sections will expire in 2005.
See
also:Discuss this
story on Plastic.com Dems Ready
Bioterrorism Bill USA Act Stampedes
Through Governor Calls
for 'Cyber Court' Conflict 2001: Fresh Perspectives
America v.
Terrorism: All the Facts
Lycos'
America Rebuilds
Resource Page
But the Dec. 2005 expiration date embedded in the USA Act --
which the Senate approved
98 to 1 on Thursday -- applies only to a tiny part of the mammoth bill.
After the president signs the measure on Friday, police will have the
permanent ability to conduct Internet surveillance without a
court order in some circumstances, secretly search homes and offices without
notifying the owner, and share confidential grand jury information with the CIA.
Also exempt from the expiration date are investigations underway by Dec.
2005, and any future investigations of crimes that took place before that date.
On Thursday, Attorney General John Ashcroft vowed to publish new guidelines
as soon as the president signs the bill, which is expected to happen Friday. "I
will issue directives requiring law enforcement to make use of new powers in
intelligence gathering, criminal procedure and immigration violations," Ashcroft
said.
President Bush said
this week that he looks forward to signing the USA Act, which his administration
requested in response to the Sep. 11 hijackings, "so that we can combat
terrorism and prevent future attacks."
During the Senate debate Thursday, the lone critic of the bill was Russ Feingold (D-Wisconsin), who
introduced an unsuccessful series of pro-privacy amendments
earlier this month.
"We in this body have a duty to analyze, to test, to weigh new laws that the
zealous and often sincere advocates of security would suggest to us," Feingold
said.
"This is what I have tried to do with this anti-terrorism bill. And that is why
I will vote against this bill."
Feingold said the USA Act "does not strike the right balance between
empowering law enforcement and protecting constitutional freedoms."
But not one of his colleagues joined him in dissent. Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-New York) seemed to
speak for the rest of the Senate when saying "the homefront is a war front" and
arguing that police needed new surveillance powers.
Sen. Mary Landrieu (D-Louisiana)
did not vote.
Other sections of the USA Act, which the House approved
by a 357 to 66 vote
on Wednesday, that do not expire include the following:
- Police can sneak into someone's house or office, search the contents, and
leave without ever telling the owner. This would be supervised by a court, and
the notification of the surreptitious search "may be delayed" indefinitely.
(Section 213)
- Any U.S. attorney or state attorney general can order the installation of
the FBI's Carnivore surveillance system and record addresses of Web pages
visited and e-mail correspondents -- without going to a judge. Previously,
there were stiffer legal restrictions on Carnivore and other Internet
surveillance techniques. (Section 216)
- Any American "with intent to defraud" who scans in an image of a foreign
currency note or e-mails or transmits such an image will go to jail for up to
20 years. (Section 375)
- An accused terrorist who is a foreign citizen and who cannot be deported
can be held for an unspecified series of "periods of up to six months" with
the attorney general's approval. (Section 412)
- Biometric technology, such as fingerprint readers or iris scanners, will
become part of an "integrated entry and exit data system" with the identities
of visa holders who hope to enter the U.S. (Section 414)
- Any Internet provider or telephone company must turn over customer
information, including phone numbers called -- no court order required -- if
the FBI claims the "records sought are relevant to an authorized investigation
to protect against international terrorism." The company contacted may not
"disclose to any person" that the FBI is doing an investigation. (Section 505)
- Credit reporting firms like Equifax must disclose to the FBI any
information that agents request in connection with a terrorist investigation
-- without police needing to seek a court order first. Current law
permits this only in espionage cases. (Section 505)
- The current
definition of terrorism is radically expanded to include biochemical
attacks and computer hacking. Some current computer crimes --
such as hacking a U.S. government system or breaking into and damaging any
Internet-connected computer -- are covered. (Section 808)
- A new crime of "cyberterrorism" is added, which covers hacking attempts
causing damage "aggregating at least $5,000 in value" in one year, any damage
to medical equipment or "physical injury to any person." Prison terms range
between five and 20 years. (Section 814)
- New computer forensics labs will be created to inspect "seized or
intercepted computer evidence relating to criminal activity (including
cyberterrorism)" and to train federal agents. (Section 816)
Related Wired Links:

Dems Ready
Bioterrorism Bill
Oct. 26, 2001
USA Act Stampedes
Through
Oct. 25, 2001
Governor Calls
for 'Cyber Court'
Oct. 18, 2001
Senator Backs Off
Backdoors
Oct. 17, 2001
House Endorses
Snoop Bill
Oct. 13, 2001
Terror Bill
Clears Senate
Oct. 12, 2001
Terror Bill
Limits Gambling, Too
Oct. 12, 2001
FBI Warns of
'Skyfall' Attack
Oct. 11, 2001
A Senator's
Lonely Privacy Fight
Oct. 11, 2001
Snoop Bill Heads
to Final Vote
Oct. 10, 2001
New Weapons for a
New War
Oct. 9, 2001
Copyright © 1994-2001
Wired Digital Inc. All rights reserved.